Latest News
▶India’s gold demand boosted by lower prices in October, with jewelry, ETFs, and imports strong – WGC’s Chacko|▶Sirios Continues to Expand Gold Mineralization at Cheechoo with an Intercept of 1.09 gt Au over 70.5 m|▶Precious metals break to new 52-week lows as us dollar reaches new 19-month high|▶Gold’s bull market will benefit from tech selloff as capital rotates back into precious metals – Jesse Colombo|▶Inflation is back - so why is gold falling?|▶Panama to start talks to assess reopening Cobre Panama mine|▶Rio Tinto restarts idled aluminium production line in New Zealand|▶Malaysia inks deal with France to develop critical minerals|▶China's concentrate-fed copper smelting capacity nears a ceiling in 2026, association says|▶Barrick invests C$5.7m to maintain Hercules Metals shareholding|▶India’s gold demand boosted by lower prices in October, with jewelry, ETFs, and imports strong – WGC’s Chacko|▶Sirios Continues to Expand Gold Mineralization at Cheechoo with an Intercept of 1.09 gt Au over 70.5 m|▶Precious metals break to new 52-week lows as us dollar reaches new 19-month high|▶Gold’s bull market will benefit from tech selloff as capital rotates back into precious metals – Jesse Colombo|▶Inflation is back - so why is gold falling?|▶Panama to start talks to assess reopening Cobre Panama mine|▶Rio Tinto restarts idled aluminium production line in New Zealand|▶Malaysia inks deal with France to develop critical minerals|▶China's concentrate-fed copper smelting capacity nears a ceiling in 2026, association says|▶Barrick invests C$5.7m to maintain Hercules Metals shareholding|
Back to News
Latest News

Brazilian tailings processor Itabiriçu escalates court action against Vale over 'ore stealing' dispute

Brazilian tailings processor Itabiriçu escalates court action against Vale over 'ore stealing' dispute
28 September 20265 Mins read

Brazilian mining company Itabiriçu is petitioning the Supreme Court of Texas to review an appellate court’s decision in its long-running lawsuit against industry rival Vale, with Itabiriçu alleging a conspiracy to dominate the Texas iron industry.

The petition raises broad questions about whether foreign companies can be sued in Texas, how closely a lawsuit must be tied to Texas conduct and how courts should analyse commercial activity that spans multiple countries and jurisdictions.

The $500-million ore processing dispute stemmed from an original lawsuit filed in October 2023 in Nueces County, Texas, which alleged Vale conspired with co-defendants Voestalpine Texas and Voestalpine US Holding to become Texas’ primary iron-ore supplier.

Vale allegedly extracted and sold more than 100-million tons of the metal rightfully owned by Itabiriçu to Voestalpine, which then shipped the processed ore through the Port of Corpus Christi.

The battle derives from a dispute between Itabiriçu and Vale over Brazil’s Research Permit Polygonal, a water-filled zone that stores mineral waste, or tailings. According to the filing, Itabiriçu has the technological capability to safely extract iron from the tailings in this area.

In September 2023, a Brazilian federal court ruled in favour of Itabiriçu, upholding the company's ownership of these tailings and the right to begin extraction efforts in the Polygonal. However, prior to that ruling Vale had extracted and sold the disputed tailings.

After the Texas trial court denied Vale’s claims as a matter of personal jurisdiction, the Texas Court of Appeals dismissed Itabiriçu's allegations of improper conversion and sale of iron-ore against Vale, ruling that the issues should lie solely in Brazil's courts.

In the petition to the Texas Supreme Court, Itabiriçu's counsel argues that the appellate court’s ruling to separate Vale's "unlawful extraction" of iron-ore in Brazil from its business dealings in Texas is flawed.

"If the court broadens its view, it's clear Vale's affiliation with Voestalpine influenced the decision to take and sell Itabiriçu's materials," says law firm Lynn Pinker Hurst & Schwegmann attorney Michael Hurst.

According to the filing, Vale created and maintained a "Texas Project" alongside Voestalpine to establish domination over iron shipping and processing in Texas. Itabiriçu also claims Vale illegally commingled the two companies' raw materials.

"For years Vale has been wrongfully storing our clients’ rightfully owned raw materials with theirs and selling them. Vale and its co-conspirators should not benefit from making our client's iron nearly impossible to trace," Hurst states. 

Our Trusted Brands

Arras Minerals
Afrikor
Arizona Gold & Silver
Astra Exploration
Aurion Resources
Bluenergies
Bactech
Digipower X
Gold Hunter Resources
Golkor
Guanajuato
Harfang
He Capital
Kodiak Copper
Leviathan
Loyalist
Mining Investment Event
Noble Plains
Pan Global
Power Metallic
SilverWolf
Spacekor
US Gold
USDC
Vivio Power
West Red Lake
Arras Minerals
Afrikor
Arizona Gold & Silver
Astra Exploration
Aurion Resources
Bluenergies
Bactech
Digipower X
Gold Hunter Resources
Golkor
Guanajuato
Harfang
He Capital
Kodiak Copper
Leviathan
Loyalist
Mining Investment Event
Noble Plains
Pan Global
Power Metallic
SilverWolf
Spacekor
US Gold
USDC
Vivio Power
West Red Lake

News & Updates

Subscribe to Our Latest News & Updates